Chief Frego read the monthly report for January 2008. Chief Frego stated that from January 1, 2008 through January 31, 2008, the members of the St. John Police Department logged 22,596 miles and responded to 478 incidents. The investigation of these incidents led to 34 adult arrests with 53 charges being filed and 7 juvenile arrests with 8 charges being filed. There were 353 traffic citations issued along with 113 written warnings for a total of 466 citations being issued during the month of January 2008 by the officers of the St. John Police Department. Also during the month of January, vehicle thefts totaled $10,000.00, and all other thefts totaled $15,425.00. The total value of recovered property was $10,000.00. Regarding grant activity, Chief Frego stated the officers of the St. John Police Department, while working the OPO / BCC / OSS / DUI Taskforce Grants, issued 66 traffic citations and 34 written warnings for a total of 100 citations being issued on the grants during the month of January 2008. The investigation of these violations resulted in 8 adult arrests with 10 charges being filed and 0 juvenile arrests with 0 charges being filed on the grants for the month of January 2008. There was a typographical error in the January 2008 Monthly Report, so Commissioner Hejl made a motion to accept the Chief’s Monthly Report for January 2008 with the number of patrol miles being logged to read as “22,596” miles. With a second by Commissioner Vale, the motion carried unanimously (3-0).
With a second by Commissioner Vale, the motion carried unanimously.
Town of St. John, Lake County
Indiana, Board of Metropolitan
Police Commissioners
______________________________
Rose Hejl, Secretary
ATTEST:
________________________________
Joan M. Kolodziej, Recording Secretary
Chief Frego stated in April 2007, the Police Department instituted the Infraction Deferral Program after the State Board of Accounts ruled that the St. John Driver Education Program could not continue. Since that time, the officers have done a tremendous job in writing tickets. To date, the Department has received approximately $63,000 through the Infraction Deferral Program. These monies have been deposited into the Police Department’s Special Equipment Fund. The attorney just filed another 146 Deferral Agreements. This has been a terrific program for the department. The monies will be used for the purchase of equipment and squad cars. In response to Commissioner Dodaro’s inquiry, Chief Frego stated this program is much better than the St. John Driver Education Program as there is no manpower involved, and there are no classes being taught. The paperwork is filed through the Law Firm of Austgen and Kuiper, and they administer the program, inclusive of filing the tickets at Lake County. The Police Department does the follow up check on the Agreements. The Police Department then issues a letter to the defendants advising whether or not they successfully completed the terms of the Infraction Deferral Agreement.
Chief Frego advised the Commission he felt discussion needed to be held regarding the future testing for the Lieutenants’ and the Sergeants’ positions. There currently is no testing or list in place at this time. Chief Frego recommended the use of the same testing company as was used with the last officer hiring; namely, Standard and Associates out of Chicago, Illinois. This firm is endorsed by the Indiana Association of Chiefs of Police. Their test is a tried and true test, and it has stood up against all the legal challenges that have been thrown at it. Chief Frego stated he would like to have an established list for Lieutenants and Sergeants by the end of Spring or the beginning of Summer. Some discussion ensued regarding scheduling an Executive Session. The Commissioner determined they would schedule an Executive Session for this purpose on Monday, April 21, 2008 at 7:30 P.M. in the Conference Room at the Town Hall, 10955 W. 93rd Avenue, St. John, Indiana.
Town of St. John, Lake County
Indiana, Board of Metropolitan
Police Commissioners
______________________________
Rose Hejl, Secretary
ATTEST:
________________________________
Joan M. Kolodziej, Recording Secretary
Town of St. John, Lake County
Indiana, Board of Metropolitan
Police Commissioners
______________________________
Rose Hejl, Secretary
ATTEST:
________________________________
Joan M. Kolodziej, Recording Secretary
Vice-Chairman – Commissioner Hejl nominated Ronald Vale for the position of Vice-Chairman. Commissioner Farris seconded the nomination. No further nominations were received. All commissioners present then cast a unanimous vote for Ronald Vale as Vice-Chairman of the St. John Police Commission for the Year 2008.
Secretary – Commissioner Farris nominated Rose Hejl for the position of Secretary. Commissioner Vale seconded the nomination. No other nominations were received. All commissioners present then cast a unanimous vote for Rose Hejl as Secretary of the St. John Police Commission for the Year 2008.
Recording Secretary – Commissioner Hejl nominated Joan Kolodziej for the position of Recording Secretary. Commissioner Farris seconded the nomination. No other nominations were received. All commissioners present then cast a unanimous vote for Joan Kolodziej as Recording Secretary for the St. John Police Commission for the Year 2008.
Town of St. John, Lake County
Indiana, Board of Metropolitan
Police Commissioners
______________________________
Rose Hejl, Secretary
ATTEST:
________________________________
Joan M. Kolodziej, Recording Secretary
Commissioner Dodaro commented that the Eligibility List for New Hires will be expiring in November 2008. Chief Frego stated that according to the Department’s Rules and Regulations, that list could be extended by the Police Commission if they so desire. Commissioner Dodaro stated the Commission could extend the Eligibility List for an additional six (6) months. Chief Frego stated there were several good candidates on that list, and he felt it did not make sense if the Department was going to hire in 2009 to go through the time and expense of creating a new list. Commissioner Dodaro stated the Commission will consider extending this list in a few months (September or October). An Executive Session will be scheduled at a later date for this purpose. Some discussion ensued.
Chief Frego advised that Lake Central School Corporation’s new superintendent was pro-School Resource Officers (SRO), and it was hopeful that the Department would be placing an officer in the high school this Fall, as well as placing an officer at Clark Middle School. The new Superintendent will be starting July 1, 2008. Much discussion ensued regarding the SRO Program. Commissioner Long suggested Chief Frego contact local police chiefs and request their input regarding the value of the SRO Program in an effort to help sell the program to the Lake Central School Corporation. More discussion ensued.
In light of the budget crisis and with gas prices rising, Commissioner Long stated he has heard rumblings of the take home cars being taken away. Commissioner Long stated he was listening to the police officers speak about car issues, and he just wanted to make sure the Chief of Police was aware that the Police Commission was available to help him with administering some of the issues at hand so that they could relieve the pressure that is on the Chief regarding these matters. Regarding the take-home car policy, Chief Frego stated he cannot take the cars away; that decision would have to come from the Police Commission. Chief Frego stated the car issue really is a political issue right now, and the Police Commission would have to discuss the matter with the Town Council to determine the direction the Council wants to go with this issue. Chief Frego stated he would like to clarify that if the public sees a St. John police officer driving his squad car in Lake County while off-duty, the officer is not doing anything wrong. The Department’s Rules and Regulations say that the officer can drive his car off-duty. However, with the current gas prices, the public does not look favorably upon this. Chief Frego stated he has asked the officers to use common sense when driving their cars off-duty because perception is not good right now.
Commissioner Dodaro stated he felt this issue needs to be addressed in an Executive Session. Commissioner Long agreed and stated that the Commission needs to look at the facts (i.e., the officer’s mileage, who is abusing this policy, limit the amount of miles that can be driven, etc.). Chief Frego stated there are numerous options that can be considered such as limiting take-home cars to only those officers who live in Town. Commissioner Long stated if the take-home vehicles are limited to only those officers who live in Town, this may cause dissention among the officers. Commissioner Long also stated if a decision is made that only the higher ranks get take-home cars, then this too would cause dissention. Budget cuts need to affect all employees, not just the front line employee. Commissioner Long stated that right now the morale is good in the Police Department and everybody likes what the Chief does. He stated he has spoken to several officers, and they all like what is going on, and have stated the work environment is much better. Commissioner Long stated they should strategize together to make things work. More discussion ensued.
Town of St. John, Lake County
Indiana, Board of Metropolitan
Police Commissioners
______________________________
Rose Hejl, Secretary
ATTEST:
________________________________
Joan M. Kolodziej, Recording Secretary
In response to Commissioner Farris’ question regarding the 4th of July holiday, Chief Frego advised it was very uneventful with a minimum amount of calls regarding fireworks. Commissioner Farris stated he felt the Town’s fireworks were very nice.
Town of St. John, Lake County
Indiana, Board of Metropolitan
Police Commissioners
______________________________
Rose Hejl, Secretary
ATTEST:
________________________________
Joan M. Kolodziej, Recording Secretary
Commander Chapranda commented that Northwestern University’s School of Police Staff and Command will begin classes at the St. John Public Safety Facility on Monday, August 25, 2008. Corporal Timothy Gardenhire and Corporal James Turturillo will be attending this class. With their completion of this class, almost all supervisors at the St. John Police Department will have gone through this program. The one remaining supervisor who has not attended the School of Police Staff and Command is Lt. Rick Kouder.
Commissioner Dodaro advised the Officer’s Eligibility List will be expiring in November. This matter will be dealt with in the next couple of months.
Town of St. John, Lake County
Indiana, Board of Metropolitan
Police Commissioners
______________________________
Rose Hejl, Secretary
ATTEST:
________________________________
Joan M. Kolodziej, Recording Secretary
Regarding the Reserve Officers, Chief Frego advised one of the new reserve officers was involved in an off duty incident and as a result, he was asked to resign. The reserve resigned without further incident.
Also presented tonight for the Commission’s approval and adoption was a revised St. John Police Department Organization Chart. On the revised chart, Commander Michael Fryzel is now in charge of Operations, which includes Patrol and Investigations. Also, the Department has a new detective, Corporal Jay Dahlin, who will be working with Captain Bernard Johnsen in Investigations. Commissioner Farris made a motion to approve and adopt the revised St. John Police Department Organization Chart as presented. With a second by Commissioner Hejl, the motion carried unanimously (3-0).
Town of St. John, Lake County
Indiana, Board of Metropolitan
Police Commissioners
______________________________
Rose Hejl, Secretary
ATTEST:
________________________________
Joan M. Kolodziej, Recording Secretary
Commissioner Hejl stated she had questions regarding several sections of the general order, inclusive of the area Commissioner Vale mentioned. Commissioner Hejl stated she really did not know what the purpose was for this revision. Chief Frego explained during the entire budget process for 2009, several meetings were held regarding the financial problems the Town is currently encountering. The Town has a projected deficit of $1.7 million in 2009. During these meetings, there were a host of suggestions made to reduce this deficit. The game plan that was arrived at was that there would be $400,000.00 in cuts made from within. Restricting the use of the squad cars fell into the scheme of things regarding the cuts the Town Council wanted to make. Chief Frego said he was instructed by the Town Council to propose a new general order regarding the department owned vehicles that would more or less fit into their way of thinking. The original thought was to park all squad cars and go to a “pool car” type of system to save money. Through negotiations and contentious discussions, it was agreed upon that he would come up with a policy that would hopefully be acceptable to the Town Council. Chief Frego stated he came up with this revision to General Order 11.01, submitted this revision to the Town Council, and they agreed upon this policy. Chief Frego stated he felt this was the best case scenario that the Department could have at this time. Further, he stated he did not believe the policy would be permanent and when times get better, it could be revisited, and it could be revised to go back to where it was. Chief Frego stated in the meantime, he felt it was the best recommendation that he could come up with for right now.
Commissioner Long stated he had a problem with the 15 mile radius restriction as he did not think it was fair and equitable. Chief Frego advised that the 15 mile radius restriction is not new to the general order as it has been there for a long time.
Commissioner Hejl asked if changes must be made, could they come up with something that would work for everyone and not just half? She suggested allowing the use of the vehicles in the tri-town area by all officers. Chief Frego stated this suggestion was proposed and then rejected by the Town Council.
Commissioner Vale queried as to whether, in all the negotiations and discussions, the miles traveled were considered in mathematical equations (i.e., the officers who live out of Town drive 15 miles off-duty or 80 miles off-duty, then multiply that number by $3.00 per gallon, which would allow one to determine the amount of savings that could be derived by not allowing the officers who live outside the town limits of St. John to drive their squads off-duty), or was this just an arbitrary thing that came up wherein it was determined that everybody who lives in Town can drive their cars off-duty while those who live outside of Town cannot? Again, Commissioner Vale stated he was not happy with the proposed revision, and he would not vote to pass the revision. Some discussion ensued pertaining to scheduling an Executive Session or a Special Meeting to discuss this matter further, which would provide the opportunity for all commissioners to air their opinions regarding the revision. Chief Frego responded to Commissioner Vale’s query by stating calculations were made, and this part of the proposed package is expected to save $6,000. Chief Frego further stated there are a lot of different things being put together to get to the amount that needs to be saved (i.e., personnel lay-offs, discontinuing the employees’ longevity pay, and reducing the officers’ clothing allowance by $500). Chief Frego advised everybody is being affected by the budget restraints.
Commissioner Vale stated he still does not understand the situation and went on to explain the way things have been over the past 30 years; specifically stating his disappointment that the Annual Fire and Police Open House was cancelled due to a cost of $5000, yet the Town continues to host events such as Halloween Houses, Christmas in the Park, etc. He stated it is wonderful to do those events for the residents of the Town unless there is a budget crunch. He felt it was wrong in any fashion to host those types of events while taking away from the employees who serve and protect the Town. Commissioner Vale stated he felt there are other ways to cut “fat” from the budget. Further, a savings of approximately $6000 in a year against a $1.7 million deficit does not make any sense to him. Chief Frego stated he felt that this discussion was being held at the wrong meeting; the Town Council meeting was last week and that is where all these items were discussed.
Commissioner Long stated all that was necessary was for the Commission to be able to see how the numbers were calculated to get to this decision. Chief Frego stated he did not do the calculations for the big scenario. Commissioner Long advised Chief Frego he understood that but since the Chief was in charge, he wanted to see the supporting numbers and how those numbers were derived. After the Commission had a chance to review those numbers, Commissioner Long felt the Commission would then have another meeting regarding this revision. Commissioner Long stated it was his opinion that what he was asking was only fair.
Commissioner Dodaro stated he agreed with Commissioner Long, and he would like to respond to some of Commissioner Vale’s comments. First of all, Commissioner Dodaro stated he was not the enemy here. He stated the way he read the general order, all police personnel were allowed to take their cars to and from work. Police personnel who live in Town are allowed to use their car within the Town. He stated he felt this policy was not hindering the citizens of the Town at all. Policemen who elect to drive their cars off duty in the Town are expected to respond to the situations that they come across or that they hear on the radio. Therefore, the citizens of the Town are not being hurt by the policy.
Commissioner Long stated he disagreed with Commissioner Dodaro, and he felt Commissioner Dodaro was missing the point. The point is that if the morale of the Police Department suffers, then the quality of police work suffers. He felt this is what they were talking about today, over small dollars, and this is something that bothers him. Commissioner Dodaro stated he agreed with Commissioner Long but this revision is coming from the Town Council. Again, Commissioner Long stated he would like to see the numbers and how those numbers were derived. Chief Frego stated the Commission should have attended the Town Council meeting to address their concerns.
Commissioner Hejl questioned how Section “C,” Item 8, which states that when an officer is not working a regular shift, he is on-call for emergency call outs, would work under this policy. Chief Frego stated the officers’ cars are at home with them. More discussion ensued regarding the on-call status of the officers. Chief Frego advised there has never been a problem with this section of the policy. In fact, Chief Frego stated about three (3) weeks ago there was an incident in Town, which was a day-time burglary, and when the off-duty officers were called out, the response was wonderful. The officers are to be commended on their response. Within 15 minutes, there were an additional six (6) squads out. Chief Frego stated this “sold” his argument about allowing the officers to take the cars home with them instead of parking them at the station.
Commissioner Farris questioned the number of officers who live outside the 15 mile radius. Chief Frego responded that there are none.
Commissioner Dodaro asked Town Council Liaison Jerri Teibel to comment on this matter. Mrs. Teibel stated there have been three (3) (public) budget meetings and the only member sitting with the Commission tonight that has been in attendance at those meetings is Joan Kolodziej. The police officers have been to those meetings as well. If the Police Commission wanted to know what was going on, as residents of this Town and as Commission members, then they probably should have been there because then they would not be asking all these questions. Mrs. Teibel then addressed Commissioner Vale regarding “Halloween Houses,” wherein she stated the “Halloween House” made the Town of St. John $37,000.00, enough to support itself and support Christmas in the Park. Therefore, this item is off the table. As far as cuts, the Police Department was not the only department that was cut. The Town Council had to fire, not lay off, two (2) employees in Building and Planning. She further stated there are a lot of cuts being made in Town, and she feels the Police Department did get whacked. Further, at last Thursday’s Town Council meeting, she stated she voted “no” on the budget.
Commissioner Dodaro stated if the Town Council wanted the Police Commission involved in these negotiations, then the Commission should have been invited. Mrs. Teibel stated no one else was invited, yet the employees showed up. Commissioner Dodaro stated he did not attend the meetings because as a resident he has no problems and that this is not his livelihood. Commissioner Long stated he did not wish to be lectured on whether he should attend Town Council meetings. Mrs. Teibel stated that when Chief Frego brought his first proposal to the Town Council, it was turned down. Chief Frego then spent a lot of time and brought another proposal to the meeting, and got “clipped” big time. Every one of the officers stood up in favor of the Chief’s proposals, and it would have been a big help if the Commission would have been there to stand up and express its concerns instead of at a venue like tonight. Mrs. Teibel went on to say she understands that the Police Commission has the bottom line and the final say regarding policies for the Police Department. The Town Council will not “step on your toes” but just for the record, she stated she voted “no” on the entire budget, the way it was laid out, the way it was presented, etc., but she felt the need to clear some things up about “Halloween Houses.” The monies earned from that event goes into a special revenue fund that no one can touch just like the Chief has a fund that cannot be used to pay electric bills. Commissioner Long stated he would like to take the emotions out of the discussion, and he would just like to see the numbers and how they came about. Mrs. Teibel advised Commissioner Long that he needed to contact Councilman Mark Barenie, as well as Financial Advisor James Bennett, regarding this matter. More discussion ensued regarding the budget, the supporting numbers, and the timeframe that this policy needs to be enforced. Chief Frego stated that all the budget cuts will become effective January 1, 2009. Commissioner Long stated he was concerned for the police officers and business in general. He stated the way the economy works is if you make a cut, historically, those items very rarely come back in play again because it is accepted behavior. Mrs. Teibel stated it is on the record that these budget cuts are temporary and not permanent. More discussion ensued on the “temporary” status of the cuts and the need for the economy to come back around before these items can come back on the table.
Chief Frego explained a similar “temporary” situation that occurred last year when a temporary moratorium was placed on the officers wherein the officers were not allowed to drive their cars while off-duty. This action was taken when the cost of gasoline skyrocketed, and it saved dollars. However, it was only temporary. Chief Frego stated he believes that this is the same thing the Town Council is trying to do now – take actions that will only be temporary. Chief Frego stated he felt the recommendations he made were “the best of both worlds.” The officers are able to retain their squad cars for driving back and forth to work; therefore, this would not impact anybody financially as far as having to purchase a car for commuting to and from work. Further, Chief Frego stated this policy allows the officers who live in Town to continue to drive in Town while off-duty, which upholds the public safety issue.
Commissioner Farris stated he personally does not have an issue with this policy since all the officers live within the 15 mile radius, and they are allowed to drive their cars to and from work. Further, he stated he did not see the driving while off-duty as being a big issue. Chief Frego stated he believed this is a trend that is going to catch on because every department is talking about it.
Commissioner Dodaro stated he felt an Executive Session was in order for the purpose of discussing the proposed amendments to this policy. Commissioner Hejl made a motion to table this matter until it can be discussed in an Executive Session. With a second by Commissioner Long, the motion carried unanimously (5-0).
Town of St. John, Lake County
Indiana, Board of Metropolitan
Police Commissioners
______________________________
Rose Hejl, Secretary
ATTEST:
________________________________
Joan M. Kolodziej, Recording Secretary
Town of St. John, Lake County
Indiana, Board of Metropolitan
Police Commissioners
______________________________
Rose Hejl, Secretary
ATTEST:
________________________________
Joan M. Kolodziej, Recording Secretary
Commissioner Dodaro stated Chief Frego and the Members of the Police Commission received correspondence dated December 1, 2008 from Leep’s Highway Garage. Commissioner Dodaro read said correspondence, which advised of Leep’s Highway Garage’s interest in being added to the St. John Police Department’s towing roster. The Commission stated they would invite Leep’s to attend the Annual Tow Meeting held at the Commission’s meeting in February. Chief Frego stated he would check into whether Leep’s currently tows for any other towns. Commissioner Dodaro stated he would like the Town Council made aware of this request.
Regarding the request from Leep’s Highway Garage, Commissioner Dodaro asked that the Commission members be provided with the directive (ordinance) that establishes the Police Department’s Tow Policy.
Town of St. John, Lake County
Indiana, Board of Metropolitan
Police Commissioners
______________________________
Rose Hejl, Secretary
ATTEST:
________________________________
Joan M. Gorcos, Recording Secretary